Skip to main content

Nutley Man Admits Conspiring with Brother to Extort Contractors


An Essex County man today admitted to conspiring to extort multiple general contractors of approximately $14,000 by using his brother’s position as a compliance safety and health officer (CSHO) with the U.S. Department of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), U.S. Attorney Philip R. Sellinger announced.

According to U.S. Attorney Sellinger, Paul Idrovo, aka “Jose Diaz” and “Paul Mejia,” 48, of Nutley, pleaded guilty to an information charging him with one count of conspiring to defraud the United States and to commit an offense against the United States, specifically to commit an act of extortion under color of his brother’s office or employment with OSHA. 

U.S. Attorney Sellinger stated that Paul Idrovo was previously charged by complaint in September 2020, together with his brother, Alvaro Idrovo, with conspiring to commit an offense against the United States based on the extortion of a single contractor.

According to documents filed in this case and statements made in court:

Alvaro Idrovo misrepresented to contractors engaged in construction sites in New Jersey that they were facing significant OSHA fines, penalties and possibly jail if they did not get OSHA safety training from a specific individual. 

He would provide the contractors with the phone number for the required trainer, allegedly named “Jose Diaz” or “Paul Mejia.” 

The phone number actually belonged to Paul Idrovo, posing under these names to conceal their relationship. 

Paul Idrovo was an authorized trainer for certain OSHA Outreach Training Programs but was not an employee of OSHA.

Although initially demanding higher sums, the two men eventually charged the contractors $4,000 to $6,000 each for the alleged safety training, which was required to be paid in cash. 

Paul Idrovo collected the cash and provided the contractors with fraudulent computer-generated safety and health certificates for their individual employees, which falsely stated that the employees had received various types of OSHA-certified safety training from “Jose Diaz” and “Paul Mejia,” when no training had been provided. 

As part of the charged fee, Paul ldrovo and Alvaro Idrovo also furnished the contractors with alleged necessary safety and health plans, which were prepared from a template rather than created or modified in any substantial way for the contractor. 

Paul Idrovo shared with Alvaro Idrovo approximately $5,000 of the cash collected as part of the extortion conspiracy. 

When OSHA officials learned of the attempt to extort one of the contractors, the OSHA officials referred the matter to federal law enforcement, who arranged for that contractor to make consensual recordings with both Alvaro Idrovo and Paul Idrovo. 

During an April 2020 meeting surveilled by law enforcement, the contractor paid Paul Idrovo $6,000 in cash in exchange for ladder and safety awareness training certificates and a safety and health plan. 

Alvaro Idrovo thereafter attached copies of the training certificates and the plan to his OSHA reports regarding the contractor’s violation despite knowing that the training certificates falsely claimed that training had been provided to the noted individuals in March 2020, “Jose Diaz” had provided training, and the alleged training was OSHA certified.